On the other hand, sorensen thinks that thought experiments in science and philosophy can be treated as of a kind. Pdf it is well established that thought experiments are both scientifically and. Philosophy, science and religion mark three of the most fundamental modes of thinking about the world and our place in it. Here are three of the most interesting thought experiments that the philosophy of mind has to offer. Thought experiments are a means of imaginative reasoning that lie at the heart of philosophy, from the presocratics to the modern era, and they also play central roles in a range of fields, from physics to politics. Recent studies in history and philosophy of science part a articles recently published articles from studies in history and philosophy of science part a. Examplesofthoughtexperiments inscience andphilosophy. Contents click on titles for links to individual pdfs preface. This semester, we will engage our brains by tackling the following big questions. Norton 44 does probability capture the logic of scientific. Contemporary debates in philosophy presents a forum for students and their teachers to follow and participate in the debates that animate philosophy today in the western world. Much significant work in philosophy depends on a vivid imagination. Thought experiments philosophy oxford bibliographies.
On the relation between experiment and thought experiment in the natural sciences. The first argues that thought experiments in philosophy and science should be treated together. To understand the reciprocal autonomy and complementarity of thought and real experiment, it is necessary to distinguish between a positive empirical or formal and a transcendental perspective. I will argue with sorensen that thought experiments in science and philosophy are of a kind. Thought experiments in science and philosophy savage, md. Scientific thought experiments especially those in physicsare the clear cases, so my primary goal is to establish true and interesting generalizations about them. Thought experiments as ideal limits and as semantic domains, in t.
A short insight about thought experiment in modern physics arxiv. Intuitions, remember, are nonsensory perceptions of abstract entities. Each volume presents pairs of opposing viewpoints on. Many of my philosophy of science students have no background in. Thought experiment acquires evidential significance only on particular metaphysical assumptions. Laymon, ronald, 1991, thought experiments of stevin, mach and gouy. Thought experiments stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The routledge companion to thought experiments 1st. A short commentary accompanies each thought experiment, highlighting the important elements of the experiment and summarizing the context in which the thought experiment developed. Alongside the actual practices of experimentation, a variety of authorsboth philosophers and philosophy minded scientistshave reflected upon the nature and function of scientific experiments. The second examines existing accounts of thought experiments. Thought experiments for philosophy 101 students mcsweeneys.
If a tree falls in the forest, but no one hears it, does it make a sound. Recent studies in history and philosophy of science part a. This text with readings helps students understand the nature and pu. The evidential significance of thought experiment in science james w. On thought experiments as a priori science article pdf available in international studies in the philosophy of science 3. The writing is wonderfully clear without being simplistic. There is no consensus on a definition, but there is widespread agreement on which are standard examples. Interesting nonpropositions i will further restrict this paper to analysing the interesting component of those theories which kant has called synthetic a posteriori propositions. Their structure and function1 lukas bielik department of logic and methodology of sciences faculty of philosophy comenius university in bratislava project apvv 014912 1. Thought experiments should, just like experiments in science, be free from confounding variables otherwise it is unclear what it is that you are testing. It doesnt really make sense to call these beginnings of philosophy not.
Thought experiments rachel cooper abstract this paper seeks to explain how thought experiments work, and also the reasons why they can fail. Looking at the development of the discussion about thought experiments over the past thirty years, it is fair to say that thought experiments were primarily an important topic in the philosophy of science and the philosophy of philosophy metaphilosophy, before the scope widened up at a later point. Introduction to philosophy of science the aim of philosophy of science is to understand what scientists did and how they did it, where history of science shows that they performed basic research very well. In this paper i too want to use this comparative method. It is a device used both in science and philosophy. Thought experiments in science university of toronto tspace. Success here will radiate to my secondary goal of understanding philosophical thought experiments. The interest of the book is clearly dependent on, and derived from, the interest and value of the technique of thought experiment in science and philosophy. Nagel acted out of empathy, assuming that the spider would fare better and perhaps even enjoy life outside of its normal existence. Thought experiments in science and philosophy philsci. The process of isolating all potentially confounding variables is the reason why the scenarios in thought experiments are often highly abstract or far fetched, not like any. This volume originated in a conference on the place of thought experiments in science and philosophy which was organized by us and held at the center for philosophy of science at the university of pittsburgh, april 1820, 1986. Pdf practicing and studying automated experimentation may benefit from philosophical reflection on.
An overview for educators peter machamer department of history and philosophy of science, university of pittsburgh, pittsburgh, pa 15260, usa description of philosophy of science and its rationale from the point of view of knowledge or epistemologically, science is a method of. Thought experiments in science, philosophy, and the arts. Naomi picked it up and couldnt help but notice the small white rabbit s foot dangling fromit. The paper addresses the question of the nature and limits of philosophical thought experiments. Philosophy of science 4 observations of physical phenomena, harder to agree on observations of social or mental phenomena, and difficult in the extreme to reach agreement on matters of theology or ethics and thus the latter remain outside the normal. Platonism in the philosophy of mathematics, though a minority. This activity is a treatment of some of the issues thrown up by a thought experiment called the trolley problem, which was first outlined by the philosopher philippa foot, and then developed by judith jarvis thomson and others. In order to figure out when this is the case, we can use cleverly constructed thought experiments to push the edges of our moral beliefs. Thought experiments and intuition pumps in philosophy ecpr. Oct 29, 2009 the rise of the philosophy of scientific experimentation. The idea behind this conference was to encourage philosophers and scientists to talk to each other about the role of thought experiments in their various disciplines.
Among the betterknown examples are bacons and galileos advocacy of the experimental method. Thought experimentation inpresocratic philosophy 31. Contents notes on contributors vii preface xi introduction. The philosophy of science is a field that deals with what science is, how it works, and the logic through which we build scientific knowledge. Oxford university press, 1992, and thought experiments and the epistemology of laws, canadian journal of philosophy 22 1992 lw. Thought experiments in science, philosophy, and the arts routledge studies in the philosophy of science. Contemporary debates in philosophy in teaching and research, philosophy makes progress through argumentation and debate. I am a philosopher with a background in art which i studied as an undergraduate. Thought experiments in methodological and historical contexts. If youre interested in reading more about utilitarianism.
Einsteins most famous thought experiment, thought experiments in philosophy, science and the arts, eds. Thought provoking questions and bibliographic entries at the end of each experiment give the reader additional resources for study. Why, what and how till gruneyanoff royal institute of technology kth, stockholm finnish centre of excellence in the philosophy of the social sciences, helsinki tint forthcoming in european journal for philosophy of science. Anyone who doubts that need only look at the person who created twerking. Only on these platonically inspired assumptions does it make sense to bypass. Think of gettierstyle cases when you read this thought experiment. Thought experiments at least in some cases allow us to intuit laws of nature. It is also widely agreed that they play a central role in a number of fields, especially physics and philosophy. Nov 09, 2017 hope you enjoyed this philosophy video and hope this made you consider taking a philosophy class next semester. Understanding the reasons behind using thought experiments, we should now understand that thought experiments can be relevant even if a situation is absurd and extremely unlikely to happen in reality.
He has published widely on topics in general philosophy of science and history and philosophy of nineteenth century physics. On the one hand, experimental philosophers are right to claim that we need much more laboratory work in order to have more reliable thought experiments, but on the other hand a naturalism that is too radical is incapable of clarifying the peculiarity of thought experiments in philosophy. If the ship of theseus has its components replaced throughout its journey, does it at any point become a different ship. Thought experiments in science, philosophy, and the arts routledge studies in the philosophy of science brown, james robert on. The future of the history of the philosophy of science. Gedankenexperiment, gedankenexperiment, or gedankenerfahrung considers a hypothesis, theory, or principle for the purpose of thinking through its consequences. International studies in the philosophy of science, 11, 115.
Thought experiments a science, philosophy, rationality. Thought experiments in science, philosophy and the arts pp. In the philosophy of science, especially, there is no clear line where the philosophy ends and the science begins. He was editor of the british journal for the philosophy of science from 1974 to 1982, and editor of the collected works of imre lakatos. Horowitz, tamara and massey, gerald 1991 thought experiments in science and philosophy. If a certain experiment is performed on u then the outcome is real number. Susan schneider is a philosophy professor at the university of connecticut and a fellow with the american council of learned societies. Evidential significance of thought experiment 243 anyone who understood the thought experiment would be compelled to reject aristotles theory of free fall for that of galileo. The routledge companion to thought experiments is an invaluable guide and reference. Introduction1 section 1 thought experiments in the history of science and philosophy. But as frightening as some of our creations can be, some ideas mostly from philosophers are so mindbending or paradoxical that they can be difficult to truly comprehend.
Philosophers use thought experiments, short stories that bring out intuitions. Mcallister the most promising way to regard thought experiment is as a species of experiment, alongside concrete experiment. It serves as a model of how id like theorizing about thought experiments to go. This interconnection may be both direct and indirect, through the whole system of culture, through science, art, morality, religion, law, and politics. The idea is certainly a good one, as science fiction at its best is all about broadly construed thought experiments, one of the primary tools of philosophers. But this generalization of the following discussion will have to await further investigation. In this website, we present a rough synthesis of some new and some old ideas from the philosophy of science. It will consider general problems of principle concerning thought experiments as well as the place and function of exemplar thought experiments largely drawn from physical sciences, but from philosophy and mathematics, as well. Philosophy offers numerous examples of thought experiments that play a role similar in importance to some scientific thought experiments.
There are several important questions about thought experiments that naturally arise. Some science is too big, dangerous, or weird to happen in the lab. Logic and the philosophy of science 45 logic and the philosophy of science bas c. Our philosophical science correspondent massimo pigliucci asks philosophers are often accused of engaging in armchair speculation, as far removed from reality as possible, inside the proverbial ivory tower. These thought experiments introduce students to the kind of disciplined thought required in philosophy, and awaken their intellectual curiosity. This thought experiment forces us to consider the quality and meaningfulness of not just animal lives. These include the thesis that science aims at uncovering phenomenauniversal and stable modes in which the world is articulatedand the thesis that phenomena are revealed imperfectly in actual occurrences. It is often not possible to do these experiments in real life, but by doing them in our heads we can learn something new about the nature of reality, about right and wrong, the existence of god and many other topics. What is philosophy of science and should scientists care. Whilst a scientist may believe that they are following the methods of kuhn or popper, there is also a tribute to aristotle, avicenna or bacon in their work. Apr 24, 2012 thought experiments for philosophy 101 students.
A short history of the method of thought experiments in science. Just about 20 years ago, i abandoned a career as a physical chemist to become a philosopher science. Philosophy of physics part b university of pittsburgh. Philosophers writing on thought experiments divide into two camps. On a kantian theory of the thought experiments in the natural sciences and philosophy article in deutsche zeitschrift fur philosophie 591. Collected thought experiments in philosophy is a brief collection of over 100 classic and contemporary thought experiments, each exploring an important philosophical argument. The modern scientific method is built upon the work of all of these great philosophers. The philosophy of mind is usually illustrated through thought experiments, which present problems to express how we understand the world and ourselves, or, rather, how we dont understand it. The touchstone of the value of philosophy as a worldview and methodology is the degree to which it is interconnected with life. The routledge companion to philosophy of science is an indispensable reference source and guide to the major themes, debates, problems and topics in philosophy of science. Comments on james brown, nancy nersessian and david gooding.
Let me begin by giving two wellknown examples of thought experiments, both drawn from natural science, where thought experiments have an accepted and. Studies in history and philosophy of science part a. James robert brown, thought experiments in science. Philosophy of physics part b edited by jeremy butterfield all souls college, university of oxford, oxford, uk and john earman department of history and philosophy of science, university of pittsburgh, pittsburgh, pa, usa amsterdam boston heidelberg london new york oxford paris san diego san francisco singapore sydney tokyo. Therefore to achieve this aim, philosophers look back to the great achievements in the evolution of modern science that. Recall frank jacksons wellknown thought experiment involving mary the scientist, in which mary has access to every. It contains sixtytwo specially commissioned entries by a leading team of international contributors. Understanding philosophy of science this is the best introduction to philosophy of science i have read. Science and philosophy from the university of edinburgh. Stuart doctor of philosophy institute for the history and philosophy of science and technology university of toronto 2015 abstract thought experiments are a means of imaginative reasoning with an employment record longer than two and a half thousand years.
Philosophy of science tries to connect the process and means of science with the questions of epistemology and metaphysics. Why some philosophers of science should engage scientific communities. The evidential significance of thought experiment in science. Rosenberg offers a superb introduction to the epistemological and metaphysical issues at stake in modern science. I am going to use this book for an undergraduate class on scifi and philosophy, so obviously i think well enough of it. Sep 10, 2012 thought experiments in science, philosophy, and the arts by melanie frappier, 9780415885447, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. These papers were either written for the conference, or were written after it by commentators and other participants. Apr 07, 2014 what is philosophy of science and should scientists care. Because they do not involve the senses, they transcend experience, and give us a priori knowledge of the laws of nature.
523 347 1463 1471 1556 744 240 1509 1132 97 1564 1139 832 57 1197 783 1239 295 1242 7 897 321 417 1093 704 923 1070 255 1578 718 645 1362 722 1326 617 174 1072 1027 203 1233 384